New from the Mott Poll: 2 in 3 parents not confident they can tell whether used children's equipment is safe

ANN ARBOR, MI -- Cribs, strollers and other infant and child equipment can be expensive and most families in a new national poll agree that it’s wasteful to buy these items new when they’re needed for such a short time.

But while half of parents say they have used pre-owned equipment for babies and young children, two in three acknowledge that it’s difficult to always know whether it’s safe for their child, according to the University of Michigan Health C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital National Poll on Children’s Health.

“Used child essentials are often more cost-effective, environmentally friendly and convenient,” said Mott Poll co-director Sarah Clark. “However, many parents in our poll weren’t completely confident they could identify safety concerns, such as unsafe wear and tear, recalls or hygiene issues.”

Half of parents polled say they are only comfortable using used infant and child equipment from family or close friends while a little less than half are also OK with items bought at resale shops and yard sales.

Parents most commonly used pre-owned cribs and highchairs, followed by outdoor play structures, strollers, playpens and bath seats, according to the poll report, which is based on responses from 932 parents with at least one child aged 0-7 surveyed in February 2023. Parents are least likely to report using second hand infant car seats or booster seats.

“Regardless of whether they receive the item from someone they know well or from a garage sale, parents should take diligent steps to make sure the equipment meets current safety standards and is safe for their child,” Clark said.

“Parents should keep in mind that safety regulations are constantly evolving as research identifies features that pose a risk of injury,” she added. “This is particularly important when it comes to cribs, one of the most common types of pre-owned equipment. It is likely that some parents using pre-owned cribs may not be aware of how safety standards have changed.”

Most parents say that when they receive or buy pre-owned equipment, they are very likely to inspect it for signs of damage and sanitize it. But just half of parents are as likely to do an Internet search for instructions on how to set up and use the equipment or for information about product recalls.

“If parents don’t properly follow assembly instructions, cribs, strollers and playsets can collapse or malfunction, potentially causing serious injuries to the child,” Clark said.

“Before allowing a child to use a pre-owned item, it’s also essential to check for product recalls, which mean a manufacturer has asked customers to return or stop using the product due to a discovered safety hazard.”

Four percent of parents polled are not comfortable using any pre-owned equipment and three-quarters say they’d prefer to buy new equipment to make sure it’s safe for their child.

But budget concerns can be a barrier, especially since families often require duplicate pieces of equipment to support their child’s sleep, transportation, and other daily activities at grandparents’ or babysitters’ homes.

Parents with household incomes under $100,000 are more likely to say they have used pre-owned equipment compared to those over $100,000 (58% vs 48%).

Most parents also say they themselves have donated or sold child health and safety equipment, most often to a family member or friend (74%) or a charitable organization (52%), as well as at a garage sale (35%) or to a children’s resale shop (33%). Another 19% say they have never shared or sold pre-owned equipment.

“Before passing on an item to another family, parents should ensure it’s safe and in good working order,” Clark said. “If not, parents should dispose of the equipment to avoid risking injury of another child.”

Clark offers more tips regarding used infant and child equipment:

Check for recalls

Parents can search for recall information from the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission along with its associated website, saferproducts.gov, which is a comprehensive search engine for all recalled products and a portal to report any products that have malfunctioned.

Safety standards also continue to change as ongoing research identifies new risks that people passing on their items may not be aware of, Clark notes. Current standards for cribs, for example, specify that they shouldn’t have a drop-side rail, the crib rails should be less than six centimeters apart and the headboard have no decorative cut-out that can trap a child’s body.

Research installation directions

Parents often receive pre-owned equipment without the original packaging. Clark recommends parents in this situation search the website of the product’s manufacturer to find online instructions.  

Poorly assembled cribs, playsets and other items pose serious injury risks to children. Without proper assembly, items could also have malfunctioning parts, such as brakes that do not work or wheels that come off on a stroller.

“To prevent these dangers, it’s important to carefully follow the manufacturer's instructions when assembling any items being used by a child, and to double-check that all parts are securely in place,” Clark said.

Do extra research for car seats

Car seats present a unique challenge, as their safety considerations vary based on the child’s age, height and weight and they typically have an expiration date.

“It’s particularly important for parents to obtain the product-specific information to ensure the car seat meets safety guidelines for their child, hasn’t been involved in a crash and that they have proper guidance for installation,” Clark said.

If parents aren’t able to find instructions or have difficulty with assembly, many fire stations or other community organizations offer assistance with installation.

Do your diligence when you’re the one donating an item

Parents passing off children’s gear should check for recalls, inspect the item for any serious wear and tear, clean the item thoroughly, make sure all the parts are included and, when possible, attach the product instructions to the equipment so that the new owners can assemble and install it correctly.

“Parents who no longer need their children’s equipment can do their part to ensure the items are safe and suitable for use by another family,” Clark said.